Current:Home > ScamsAfraid your apartment building may collapse? Here are signs experts say to watch out for. -MarketEdge
Afraid your apartment building may collapse? Here are signs experts say to watch out for.
View
Date:2025-04-16 23:11:03
NEW YORK ‒ On Monday, a seven-story tenement building in New York City partially collapsed, heaping a 12-foot mound of debris on the street and forcing over 170 people, including dozens of children, from their homes.
The dangerous incident followed complaints to authorities and a subsequent inspection. Experts say people living in older buildings across the country can learn from the circumstances surrounding the unexpected collapse.
While the only way to be certain of a building's structural integrity is to have it professionally evaluated, there are some red flags people can watch out for, experts told USA TODAY.
Is your building crumbling?
Abi Aghayere, a civil engineering professor at Drexel University who has studied structural failures for decades, said "tell-tale signs" of degradation include water intrusion; sagging ceilings; and cracks that seem to be expanding in walls. Residents should report all of these issues to the building owner, their landlords or the city they live in, Aghayere said.
Norbert J. Delatte, a professor of engineering at Oklahoma State University, said structural warnings most often appear in the form of changes: windows that no longer open, doors that are sticking, strange sounds, growing or moving cracks.
A good way to tell if a crack is expanding is to fill it in with spackle, Delatte said. If it opens up again, that could be a sign of trouble. Delatte also suggested people who are worried about their building should get a long level and see if their floors are drooping over time.
Both Aghayere and Delatte agreed while it's good to be vigilant, they cautioned against overzealous do-it-yourself inspections.
"If you start being hypersensitive to how your house is sounding and you start looking for cracks, you might get false positive indicators," Delatte said.
Bronx building's facade was deemed unsafe; complaints piled up
For years, people living at 1915 Billingsley Terrace complained that the building seemed to be crumbling around them.
In 2015, one resident warned in a complaint filed with the City of New York Department of Buildings that "THE BUILDING IS HIGHLY UNSTABLE. YOU CAN HEAR IT CRACKING AND DETERIORATING FROM THE INSIDE." Another complaint said the building was "OVERCROWDED" and that there were "CRACKS IN THE EXTERIOR WALLS," records show. These complaints were resolved by the city's buildings department.
In 2020, significant cracks around the building and other issues were meticulously recorded in an evaluation of the tenement's facade – the exterior walls that, in this case, were bearing the weight of the 96-year-old structure. New York City code requires owners of buildings higher than six stories to have the exterior walls inspected every five years.
Richard Koenigsberg, the engineer hired to inspect the Morris Heights building in 2020, determined the facade was "unsafe" but noted that it was not "imminently hazardous." The report never triggered a deeper inspection of the building's structural integrity, which would have had to be initiated by the owner, records show.
At a news conference on Monday night, James Oddo, the commissioner of the New York City Department of Buildings, mentioned Koenigsberg's report with the caveat that "Unsafe facade conditions is not the same as an unsafe building."
Repairs on the facade above the first floor were completed recently, Koenigsberg told USA TODAY. He said contractors were working on repairs leading up to Monday but that they were not working on the area where the building crumbled.
Koenigsberg said he believes the structural column at ground level of the building's northeast corner is to blame for the collapse – not the facade.
At the time when he submitted reports detailing the building's cracked bricks, damaged mortar and bowed parapet, Koenigsberg did not see its collapse "as foreseeable," he said.
The city's buildings department is investigating the cause of the incident, and the Bronx district attorney's office is looking into whether there was any potential criminal action. The building is owned by the shell company 1915 Realty LLC, which did not respond to requests for comment.
Aging housing, calls for more oversight
As America's housing stock ages, experts have advocated for greater oversight to prevent collapses. In New York City, which has had two prominent building collapses this year, the median residential building is almost 90 years old.
New York City Mayor Eric Adams acknowledge the age of tenements throughout the city at a news conference on Tuesday. “Many of our buildings come from an older stock," he said. "You have this from time to time.”
At the same conference, Deputy Mayor for Operations Meera Joshi said the city's buildings department does not employ enough staff to inspect all buildings citywide, and that they're looking to "sharpen tools," such as escalating fines to ensure landlords keep up with inspections and repairs.
"We're a city of millions of buildings and 500 and something inspectors," she said. "We will never – with boots on the ground – get to every building."
Aghayere said he hopes fines and other proposed sanctions prove effective in ensuring owners maintain their buildings because "this issue is not going away."
"I could find myself living in a building like that, and I can understand the apprehension that folks may be having," he said. "They need more protection."
Christopher Cann is a breaking news reporter for USA TODAY. Reach him via email at [email protected] or follow him on X @ChrisCannFL.
veryGood! (521)
Related
- Juan Soto praise of Mets' future a tough sight for Yankees, but World Series goal remains
- Ambitious Climate Proposition Faces Fossil Fuel Backlash in El Paso
- Tesla board members to return $735 million amid lawsuit they overpaid themselves
- Shawn Johnson Is Pregnant, Expecting Baby No. 3 With Husband Andrew East
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- Washington’s Biggest Clean Energy Lobbying Group Pushes Natural Gas-Friendly Policy
- Shawn Johnson Weighs In On Her Cringe AF Secret Life of the American Teenager Cameo
- Save $28 on This TikTok-Famous Strivectin Tightening Neck Cream Before Prime Day 2023 Ends
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Restoring Watersheds, and Hope, After New Mexico’s Record-Breaking Wildfires
Ranking
- Trump suggestion that Egypt, Jordan absorb Palestinians from Gaza draws rejections, confusion
- Louisiana Regulators Are Not Keeping Up With LNG Boom, Environmentalists Say
- In Northern Virginia, a Coming Data Center Boom Sounds a Community Alarm
- Environmentalists Praise the EPA’s Move to Restrict ‘Forever Chemicals’ in Water and Wonder, What’s Next?
- Head of the Federal Aviation Administration to resign, allowing Trump to pick his successor
- Lady Gaga once said she was going to quit music, but Tony Bennett saved her life
- Shawn Johnson Is Pregnant, Expecting Baby No. 3 With Husband Andrew East
- Lady Gaga once said she was going to quit music, but Tony Bennett saved her life
Recommendation
Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
Legislative Proposal in Colorado Aims to Tackle Urban Sprawl, a Housing Shortage and Climate Change All at Once
The Best Prime Day Candle Deals: Nest, Yankee Candle, Homesick, and More as Low as $6
Selena Gomez's Sister Proves She's Taylor Swift's Biggest Fan With Speak Now-Inspired Hair Transformation
The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
Las Vegas Is Counting on Public Lands to Power its Growth. Is it a Good Idea?
Do Solar Farms Lower Property Values? A New Study Has Some Answers
Outdated EPA Standards Allow Oil Refineries to Pollute Waterways